Hi all, I have run a 3-family Airbnb (all 3 units are their own Airbnbs) in the Hudson River Valley in NY for a year. Prior to this, I ran an Airnbn in Bklyn, NYC for 5 years. And I am a superhost.
My units are all clearly advertised as no-pets. I know if a pet is a service animal, I can’t say no. I can’t even ask to see proof of such certification (accdg to Airbnb). I only had one guest, up to now, who had a service dog. He told me she was coming, she came, she was good. No complaints.
Today, my husband was in the basement of the house getting some tools and heard a dog barking from one of our units. Seems the guest checked in with her service dog without giving me a heads up. Mind you, we had several exchanges beyond the usual “delighted to host you” ones. (She wanted to clarify the work space). So she had ample time to tell me, the host of a clearly marked No Pets Airbnb, that she was, in fact, bringing her service dog. And a clearly marked Victorian 3-family where the walls are thin (and yes, I say all of this in the listings).
After husband heard said dog (and not knowing if it was just a pet or a service animal), I both texted her and posted on the Airbnb messaging that we hear a dog, the dog has to go somewhre else. She, of course, shot back the bit about the service animal and her rights. I responded: “I do not appreciate you not telling me in advance. That is not cool.”
She responded (on text only): "I hear you and I apologize, in hindsight I should have mentioned something. We’ve looked through the Airbnb terms of use carefully as it relates to service animals, and they make it clear that, because of the role service animals play in peoples lives, there is no need to make a mention of it.
This is not a luxury - he serves a crucial need for me, and I genuinely am not able to travel without him. He’s professionally trained and doesn’t shed, and we’ll be sure to be more vigilant about the barking."
I did not respond. Not much more to say, really…
So my question to you, fellow hosts: do you think it’s fair to ding her on poor “communication” in her review? I am very inclined to do so, but since I’ve never had this happen and there is prickliness and disability-rights issues around this, I thought I’d check in.