I’m so with you there, from my own experience. My house in Canada was an interesting one- it had at one point been 2 houses, one of which was moved there and attached at some point. The place was about 80 years old when I bought it in 1982. It had 3 bedrooms upstairs, one down, one small bathroom, and the kitchen was galley-style, dark, and small. It was sitting in the dirt on rotted wooden foundations, needed plumbing and electrical upgrades, and insulation, and the whole place needed tons of work.
I don’t know how you’d characterize the style- it had a couple of stained glass windows in the porch and entry door, shiplap fir walls in some parts, wooden shingle outer walls and roof. Interior doors much like yours. The downstairs floors were tongue-in-groove fir, the upstairs just fir boards. It was quite the hodge podge.
Between govt. grants that were available for essential upgrades, like a proper foundation, electric and plumbing and insulating, having a couple boyfriends in a row who were carpenters (I didn’t choose them on that basis, honest) and my interest and skills in renovations, it slowly got revamped over the 18 years I lived there, keeping the original feel of the place intact. We took out some walls to open up the downstairs space, and built an addition on the back to push out the kitchen and change the kitchen layout. I found old windows and beams at demolition resale places that fit the era and style of the house.
When I went to put it on the market, the real estate agent told me I should repaint the whole interior white and I’d be really lucky to get $230,000CAN for it. I listed at $265,000, which the agent argued about.
I had put a lot of work over the years into the paint job- used lots of colors and almost no white and there was no way I was repainting.
The very first people who came to view it said they had been looking for a cool old house like that for 2 years, said “we love the colors!” and put an offer in on the spot. We negotiated to $255,000.
They have put a lot of work and money into it since they bought it in 2010, but what I’m really happy about is that they haven’t tried to make it look “modern”- they just did things I couldn’t afford to do, like reshingle the outside and put on a new roof. They also built a mother-in-law suite echoing the style of the house at the back of the yard, and took down the rotting old shed. I don’t know what they’ve done inside, but I suspect it isn’t shiny modern.
There were so many modern generic houses on the market, but I just knew the right person would come along for mine, because it was unique. I never did anything to the house with resale value in mind, I just did what I personally liked and what suited the style.