That was my goal, he was a good guest and I’m sure had no intentions of irritating me!
EDIT TO ADD REVIEW: Here’s what I ended up saying:
Thanks Mr. X for an easy pleasant stay! We enjoyed Mr. X’s company and chatting with him very much. He’s very interesting and wise, so the conversations were great! XYZ had great communication in regards to his check-in. He left his private areas and common areas clean and tidy. We hope that he slept well here, as his bedroom door appeared to be open at night and we do share a common (squeaky) hallway to guest/host bedrooms…We would welcome Mr.X back any time and highly recommend to other hosts!
A little sickeningly sweet, but I was trying to over-compensate for the open door portion of the review.
Thanks for the input all.