I don’t allow my cell or computers to do automatic updates but it’s still a good idea to check for them.
So I just crossed out dedicated workspace from my amenities, which was the feature the algorithm picked out to highlight at the top of my listing, even though there is a built-in countertop and chair in the guest room, where my guests set up their laptops or write, because I don’t cater to digital nomads and my wifi is not necessarily reliable or as high speed as guests might be used to.
So now what the algorithm highlighted at the top of my listing is Free Parking, when only 3 of my guests have ever come here with a car- they almost all fly in and take the bus from the airport.
ARGGGGGGH!!!
It’s unconscionable that an algorithm is given the power to market things about our listings which we know are not important to the majority of guests who are attracted to or a good fit for our listings.
I am about ready to throw in the towel.
4 Likes
My first thought, exactly. Sure, there will be a honeymoon period of happy hosts reporting their quick, generous resolutions, then - back to SNAFU?
I have a lakefront property in an area that is pretty much all Lakefront rentals. When you click the lake front tab no property within 50 miles shows up. So tech support says this is just for outstanding property. But when a renter clicks that Tab and thinks they will see all lakefront properties, and they don’t see any, of course they will think there are none available. They don’t know that it is only a select few properties. So they will decide they can’t rent or move to another platform to search for a lakefront property. Airbnb is forcing me to move to those other platforms so renters will see my lakefront property. The algorithm is a failure. My own property has amazing views and a 4.9 rating with a superhost. But it and dozens more disappear from the search when you do the obvious thing and select lakefront. I’m now searching for other platforms and classifieds to put my lakefront property in so that renters will actually see it
9 Likes
@Wprsly
This new rollout is a huge international problem. Air has put themselves into a corner over this and will make one excuse after another as to why this works and that doesn’t work.
The logical thing for Air to do is to withdraw this crap rollout to stop causing hosts major anxiety in not getting bookings. This, of course, will never happen.
Welcome to the new Airbnb, not host or guest friendly but it sure did cause a big splash in presentation.
Lots of hosts will be bailing from the platform, but never fear, there is an endless supply of naive new ones.
4 Likes
Airbnb needs to hear both the problems and solutions. Please comment int he Community Center, tweet, and comment on Facebook. See my post here on what I did Tweets - can we influence Airbnb? Will it do any good? Who knows - but we have seen other not so good ideas go quietly away.
3 Likes
Not a tweeter or facebook user.
Think if Air saw the hundreds of negative comments on the Community forum they might have a small clue as to how this is not going to work out for anyone.
1 Like
Still can’t find my duplex when I do a private search.
I have just jiggled the listing description to see if that makes it appear.
Views have plummeted!
Thank goodness for direct bookings.
I am ok until the end of June and then there is nothing but an empty calendar.
I feel like my historic homes are being pushed into a box that they just can’t fit into.
3 Likes
I don’t seem to be in any categories. I can find my listing on a blind search with dates, not touching categories, and it is as usual in appearance and wording.
HOWEVER we have had zero bookings since this was rolled out! 
AND my listing type is (I think) right in the realm of which they desire to feature<><>… 
THE BOTTOM LINE is going to eventually bite Airbnbn in the a$$ so hopefully it won’t take forever to fix this.
I have jumped on the Outdoorsy train and am considering Vrbooo and BOOKIII,com. Any advice on those new 2 me venues? Thanks!
Why did they change the category that included RV to just Camping? If there are really so many Castles, Tipis, Shamizens and Caves, WHY can’t there be a category for Glamping, Vintage trailers, Airstreeeams and/ or Spartans??
3 Likes
Because guests are totally confused as to how to book now, or do a regular search, since this category mess is thrown in their face first thing.
I find it hard to believe Airbnb isn’t seeing a huge drop in bookings and paying attention to it. They aren’t just frustrating and losing hosts, they are losing guests, so as you say, hopefully they will realize the error of this new presentation and do something about it soon.
1 Like
Well, somebody’s algorithm is working! This VRBO ad just popped up on my Microsoft feed:
“Rent Out Your Vacation Home – We Respect Homeowner Policies.”
8 Likes
If it makes you feel any better, I found your listing under camping and Los Angeles area.
2 Likes
Let’s just hope they are getting plenty of negative feedback from guests, and seeing a big drop in overall bookings, since whether hosts are happy with what category they’ve been placed under, or upset that their cover photo had been changed wouldn’t be anything Airbnb would care about.
1 Like
I love VRBO. It’s been good to me. DISCLAIMER: their CS is just as useless as AirBNBs BUT the damage deposit is real & I’ve rarely had to call them.
They don’t allow you to set a stay limit but I have it in my rules (max 10 days w/o host approval) and “contract”. With my booking pace between Air and VRBO it’s not been an issue (someone booking for a longer time than I want).
I also like their cancellation policy options better.
I’m only on AirBnB because (1) the volume of users they attract (2) the commission is less than VRBO but my prices are slightly higher there to compensate and (3) I couldn’t legit be in this awesome forum otherwise 
.
6 Likes
So well put, yet sadly true. I’m surprised to see that the algorithm/HAL has not tweaked my listing yet, but am realistically waiting for the other foot to fall.
1 Like
I’m currently unlisted so I have no idea what this will do to my listing. I suspect nothing because I’m not a vacation destination, don’t have a view, beach, pool or anything special for that matter.
1 Like
Same here, no changes at all for me, except for the one split-stay booking. And I’ve been playing around with the themes and the changes to the listings only exist when searching by theme. All of the photos and everything are in the normal order when searching for a specific location.
I really love it as a guest! I did a search for “barns” and was shown a bunch of listings with the first photo being of a barn, which seems useful to me. I wouldn’t want to search for barns and see a photo of the kitchen. But when I searched the area without choosing “barns”, the first photo was different (sadly, not of the barns), presumably the photo that the host chose to be first (which should probably be of a barn, lol).
But I guess I would be annoyed if I was renting out a barn and my barn didn’t show up under barns. I wish they would do a “Doggie Delight” or something theme, for places that are especially good for dogs. I bet our big backyard would be put in the first photo position.
1 Like
The view of the Grand Pitons is considered one of the premium views of the Caribbean. When jade mountain shows their ad ( which is well known) they show the view… not the pool the 2 gorgeous models are relaxing in. This is truly a home with an amazing view !
2 Likes
@muddy I am so with you on this whole new algorithm taking over our listings. I literally search for a listing as if I am a Guest looking for an Airbnb in my area and instead of my listing in my city, I am being directed to listings over 30 miles from my listing, even though I specifically state I am looking for a listing in my city. How does that makes sense? On top of that, I am now like on the 10th. page of listings, where I used to always pop up on the top 10 listings in my area. I also see that Guests cannot filter listings based on Superhosts anymore. Maybe I’m not tech savvy enough to figure that one out. It’s just horrible
The Superhost filter is in the same place, it’s still there. You don’t have to be tech-savvy, you just click on the filters as you did in the past.
Then you must be clicking on one of new themes. But even then, if you zoom in on the map to the level of your city, you will then only see listings in your city. But, yes, if you choose “beach” or something then it zooms out and you see listings from a much further distance.