It all depends on your needs!
I use August & August Connect in addition to physical keys in a lock box because my guests need a physical fob to get into the condo building, and it’s great. Whenever someone books my place they get an automated email with access details, and I often use the August Connect to lock and unlock the door remotely for guests and cleaners. Most guests don’t actually use the August at all, they just use the physical key. I also can’t change the exterior lock appearance which makes August the perfect option since it attaches to the existing deadbolt.
The Schlage keypad looks like a better option if you want your guests to use it instead of physical keys and don’t care about having on-demand remote access for yourself.